New survey claims Brits want Love Island and Big Brother axed

But the reality of this reality telly is more complicated…

Two of the UK’s biggest reality ITV2 juggernauts — Love Island and Big Brother — have topped a new list of shows that some viewers say should be cancelled in 2026.

But despite the haters, both programmes remain among the most-watched and most talked-about series on British television.

A new YouGov survey for OLBG.com suggests that 36% of Brits believe the time is up for both shows, placing them jointly at the top of the “most wanted cancelled” list.

Long-running structured reality shows like The Only Way is Essex (30%), Geordie Shore (24%) and Made in Chelsea (22%) also featured prominently.

Love Island: ITV2 and ITVX / Pictured: Harry, Blu, Alima, Tommy, Megan, Helena, Ben, Sophie, Meg, Sharkia, Dejon & Conor.

The findings point to a degree of franchise fatigue — but they don’t tell the whole story.

Both Love Island and Big Brother continue to pull in large audiences across broadcast and streaming, drive nightly social media conversation, and deliver some of the most-watched entertainment moments each year on ITV2 and ITVX.

Even the survey’s lower-ranked shows, including Strictly Come Dancing (16%) and The Apprentice (14%), remain staples of the British TV calendar with millions tuning in annually.

Top 10 shows Brits most want cancelled in 2026:
  1. Love Island (36%) & Big Brother (36%)
  2. The Only Way Is Essex (30%)
  3. I’m A Celebrity… Get Me Out of Here! (25%)
  4. Geordie Shore (24%)
  5. Made in Chelsea (22%)
  6. Strictly Come Dancing (16%)
  7. The Apprentice (14%)
  8. First Dates (6%)
  9. The Great British Bake Off (5%) & Gogglebox (5%)
  10. The Traitors / The Celebrity Traitors (4%)
The Great British Bake Off: Channel 4 / Pictured Noel Fielding, Alison Hammond, Paul Hollywood and Pru Leith

Jake Ashton, Entertainment Editor at OLBG, says the results reflect shifting viewer expectations rather than a sudden collapse in popularity:

“A few years ago the idea of Love Island or Big Brother being on the brink would have been impossible to imagine, but with over a third calling for both to be cancelled, it’s clear the audience has hit a saturation point.

“What stands out is how many long-running structured reality shows have slipped away — viewers want formats that evolve rather than repeat the same formulas.”

Ashton also notes that the comparatively low score for The Great British Bake Off — just 5% want it axed — shows the opposite effect: “Bake Off keeps evolving, and audiences clearly still love it. In a landscape where even the biggest reality shows are losing viewers, holding onto that level of support is impressive.”

Despite the critique, most of the programmes listed remain ratings heavyweights. Love Island and Big Brother continue to anchor primetime schedules, while I’m A Celebrity and Strictly regularly dominate weekly viewing charts. Industry observers say the results point to a desire for reinvention, not wholesale rejection.

Alan Carr, has been uncloaked in a brand-new look at Madame Tussauds London
The star of 2025? Alan Carr, according to the public

The survey also asked Brits to name the standout reality TV figure of 2025 — and one name dominated.

Riding the wave of The Celebrity Traitors’ huge success, Alan Carr was chosen by 47% of respondents, making him the most iconic reality TV personality of the year.

Other top names included:
• Joe Marler (Celebrity Traitors, 8%)
• Richard Storry (Big Brother, 6%)
• The full Celebrity Traitors cast (5%)
• Celia Imrie (Celebrity Traitors, 2.5%)

The popularity of The Traitors and its celebrity spin-off — both critically praised and major ratings hits — suggests that while some formats may be tiring, appetite for inventive, high-drama reality TV remains sky-high.