In Monday night’s programme new revelations came to light…
A confidential agreement between the Post Office and Fujitsu shows the technology company had authorisation to alter subpostmasters’ branch accounts, contradicting years of claims used to prosecute hundreds of people over the Horizon IT system, according to an investigation by Channel 4 News.
The 26-page document, dating from 2006 and marked “Commercial in Confidence”, explicitly allows Fujitsu to amend centrally held transaction data with Post Office permission. It also includes provisions making Fujitsu liable for penalty payments of between £100 and £150 for each faulty transaction, indicating that both parties were aware of potential errors in the system.
The Post Office and Fujitsu repeatedly told courts it was not possible to alter branch accounts remotely, a position relied on in criminal and civil cases against at least 900 subpostmasters. Many were convicted, bankrupted or otherwise financially ruined, with at least 13 suicides linked to the scandal.
The document, titled Reconciliation Service; Service Description, was not disclosed during prosecutions or civil actions. It was uncovered among papers published to the Post Office Horizon IT public inquiry website, just a week after closing statements were heard by the inquiry.
Ron Warmington, the forensic accountant appointed by the Post Office to investigate Horizon, described the contract as “dynamite”. He told Channel 4 News it “completely contradicts and undermines the assertion that there was no capability to amend branch accounts”. He added: “It’s hard to describe the covering up of this document as anything other than a lie. It’s downright deceptive and frankly evil.”
The contract sets out a reconciliation process under which discrepancies between branch records and the central database could be identified and corrected centrally, subject to Post Office authorisation. On page 17, it outlines financial penalties payable by Fujitsu where errors were found.
Legal experts said the document would have fundamentally altered the outcome of past cases. Paul Marshall, a lawyer who represented a number of subpostmasters, said the agreement “destabilises the Post Office’s position” and would have caused prosecutions to collapse had it been disclosed.
Referring to the 2006 case of Lee Castleton, he said the litigation was based on the claim that the Post Office did not know of substantial data integrity problems. “This document is entirely inconsistent with that position,” he said.
Castleton, whose case was dramatised in ITV’s Mr Bates vs the Post Office, said the revelation made him feel “physically sick”. Speaking to Channel 4 News, he said the existence of the contract showed that companies had denied something they had explicitly planned for.
“Of course it would have made a difference,” he said. “We’re now talking about accounts that can be adjusted remotely, and a contract in place for how that should be done.”
He renewed calls for a Hillsborough-style law to compel public bodies to disclose information honestly. “People have taken their lives,” he said. “We needed that law 20 years ago.”
Channel 4 News previously revealed covert recordings in which Post Office officials discussed Fujitsu’s ability to access branch systems remotely, again contradicting official claims.
In a statement, the Post Office said it “apologise[d] unequivocally for the hurt and suffering” caused by the Horizon scandal and said it was working transparently with the public inquiry, delivering financial redress and establishing a restorative justice programme. Fujitsu said the matters were subject to forensic investigation by the inquiry and it would not comment while the process was ongoing.
