Can you spot a liar? The Traitors is teaching us the skills

Can you win your way to the top of the castle like Rachel and Stephen did?

Since its latest premiere on 1 January, The Traitors has captured the nation’s imagination, with Google Trends reporting a 200% spike in search interest and a 40% increase compared to the same period last year.

From fans hunting down Claudia Winkleman’s duck jumper to reading Harriet Tyce’s novels in order, viewers are also obsessing over spotting liars—scrutinising contestants’ over-explaining, sudden confidence, and nervous tics.

But while audiences may feel they can catch a lie by instinct alone, the reality is far more nuanced.

According to Betmaster, the behaviours viewers focus on are the very same “bluffing tells” that poker and card game players have relied on for generations—and most people dramatically overestimate how good they are at spotting deception.

So You Think You Can Spot a Tell

Fans of The Traitors often believe that body language or speech patterns reveal lies. Commonly observed behaviours include:

  • Over-explaining: Adding too much detail may seem suspicious, but can also be a way to control the story.
  • Fidgeting or shifting posture: Nervous movements are often misread as guilt rather than natural anxiety.
  • Sudden confidence: Appearing overly assured can be a personal style or a strategy, not necessarily deception.
  • Avoiding eye contact: Many assume liars won’t meet the gaze, though deliberate eye contact can also deceive.
  • Pauses or stammering: Hesitation may reflect careful thinking or fatigue, not lying.

“True expertise, whether at a card table or in reality TV, relies on patterns, probability, and context—not instinct or gut feeling,” says Game Theory Expert Robert Mardisalu of Betmaster.

Better Ways to Catch a Bluff

Instead of relying on instinct or visible tells, experts say spotting deception comes down to observing patterns, context, and probability. Betmaster highlights practical ways this translates both to card games and the strategies on The Traitors:

  • Track behaviour over time: Look for consistent patterns rather than one-off gestures.
  • Observe strategy, not stress: Consider who benefits from a lie and when it occurs.
  • Use probabilities: Calculate the likelihood of certain moves or statements instead of assuming guilt.
  • Compare across players: Spot deviations from a contestant’s normal behaviour rather than general nervous signals.
  • Stay objective: Avoid letting expectations or past experiences dictate your judgement.

“Shows like The Traitors are fascinating because they highlight how humans think they can spot a liar,” Mardisalu adds. “Viewers focus on over-explaining, fidgeting, or sudden confidence, believing these behaviours are sure signs of deception. Psychologists call this confirmation bias—we notice and remember actions that fit our expectations while ignoring everything else.”

In reality, whether at a poker table or watching reality TV, success comes from tracking repeated behaviours, analysing strategy, and weighing probabilities rather than relying on a single nervous tic or pause.

“Of course, it’s also entertaining to watch and guess along with the nation. I’ll be tuning in Friday night, just like everyone else, to see who comes out on top and which contestants can truly bluff their way to victory.”