F1 pundits react to dramatic 2026 Australian Grand Prix as Mercedes dominate and Ferrari strategy sparks debate

Up To Speed hosts Naomi Schiff, Will Buxton and Jolie Sharpe break down the chaotic season opener — from George Russell’s commanding win to Oscar Piastri’s heartbreaking home race exit

The 2026 Formula 1 season has kicked off in dramatic fashion — and the team behind the Up To Speed have delivered their verdict on an eventful opening weekend.

In the latest episode, released this week, presenters Naomi Schiff, Will Buxton and Jolie Sharpe unpack the talking points from the Australian Grand Prix, including a dominant victory for Mercedes-AMG Petronas Formula One Team, fresh scrutiny over Scuderia Ferrari’s race strategy and heartbreak for home favourite Oscar Piastri.

The panel suggested Mercedes may already have mastered Formula 1’s new regulations after George Russell delivered a commanding win in Melbourne.

Schiff said the early result could be a sign that one team has already cracked the sport’s latest technical era.

“Often when we have these new eras, the first winner is the one who truly understood the regulations — and this looks like no exception,” she said.

Buxton agreed, adding: “George Russell and Mercedes have come out on top in the new F1 era, winning the first race of the season in Australia.”

The weekend also saw Scuderia Ferrari come under fire after missing a crucial pit window that could have changed the outcome of the race.

Sharpe didn’t mince her words when assessing the team’s call.

“Did Ferrari mess up their strategy? The short answer is yes,” she said.

Buxton added that the team should have taken a more aggressive approach with their drivers.

“At the very least they should have split the strategies — sacrifice one car to fight for the win.”

New power units spark debate

The trio also debated the impact of Formula 1’s new power unit regulations, with some questioning whether the nature of overtaking has changed.

Buxton suggested many moves were now influenced by energy management rather than outright racing.

“A lot of the passes are happening because of who’s harvesting, who’s lifting and coasting — is that racing?” he said.

Schiff countered that, regardless of the technical debate, the changes had improved the spectacle.

“You can say what you want, but it definitely made for more interesting racing for spectators.”

One of the weekend’s biggest talking points came before the race had even started, when Australian driver Oscar Piastri crashed on the way to the grid.

“Incredibly, the home hero crashed on the way to the grid — his race was over before it even began,” Buxton said.

Schiff added: “Honestly, it couldn’t have gone worse. His whole grandstand was there waiting to cheer him on.”

Elsewhere in the episode, the presenters praised the next generation of Formula 1 talent — including Kimi Antonelli, who impressed on debut by finishing in the points.

“There is definitely something special about Kimi Antonelli,” Schiff said.

Sharpe added: “To finish in the points on your Formula One debut — hats off.”

The podcast also highlighted an encouraging first outing for Audi F1 Team, who scored points in their debut race as a works team, while concerns were raised about Aston Martin Aramco Formula One Team after a weekend plagued by reliability problems.

The full episode of Up To Speed is available now on Global Player and all major podcast platforms.