Documentary ‘OnlyFans: Inside the Machine’ exposes allegations of exploitation and control

Amber Haque investigation explores claims of coercion, violence and regulation gaps in UK-based OnlyFans management ecosystem

A new investigation for BBC Three and BBC One has uncovered serious allegations of exploitation, coercion, violence and potential modern slavery within parts of the OnlyFans management industry, raising urgent questions about oversight in one of the UK’s fastest-growing digital creator economies.

The documentary, OnlyFans: Inside the Machine, presented by Amber Haque, examines how “OnlyFans managers” — often referred to as OFMs — operate within a largely unregulated ecosystem that has grown rapidly alongside the platform’s commercial success.

The film highlights claims that some young women feel trapped in controlling management arrangements, with allegations including unfair revenue splits, coercive contracts, account access disputes, threats and, in some cases, violence.

The programme also explores how Manchester has become a significant hub for the UK’s OnlyFans creator community, with entire office floors reportedly converted into content production studios designed to support high-output digital subscription businesses.

At the centre of the investigation is the rise of self-styled OFM agencies, which promise creators rapid audience growth and increased earnings in exchange for a percentage of income. However, the documentary raises concerns that the lack of formal regulation has enabled abusive practices to emerge in some cases.

One contributor, Rebecca from South Wales, shares her experience of working with an agency after starting on OnlyFans in 2025. She describes initially agreeing to a revenue split before the terms shifted and access to her account was allegedly taken over by the agency.

She claims the working relationship deteriorated into verbal abuse and controlling behaviour, and says she was later pressured into sex work — which she refused. Rebecca also alleges she received threats directed at her and her family, including her daughter, and describes a later physical attack at her home following a breakdown in the relationship with the agency.

The documentary also features insights from creators and researchers examining the wider ecosystem, including concerns that accounts and contracts can be transferred or traded between managers without creators’ knowledge, effectively changing control of income streams and audiences without consent.

Cybersecurity researchers from DataExpert, featured in the programme, claim to have observed online activity suggesting threats, hacking attempts and potentially exploitative behaviour within some OFM networks. They also raise concerns about how creator profiles and client relationships may be exchanged between agencies in ways that lack transparency.

The investigation highlights the legal grey area surrounding whether such practices could, in some circumstances, intersect with modern slavery legislation in England, particularly where coercion or control is alleged.

A separate interview with adult content creator Lily Phillips explores the appeal and risks of the platform, with Phillips noting the lack of formal guidance or safeguards for young entrants into the industry and calling for clearer regulation and support structures for creators navigating rapid financial and personal pressures.

While OnlyFans has repeatedly positioned itself as a creator-led platform focused on empowerment and independence, the documentary presents a more complex picture of how third-party management structures may operate around it.

In response to the programme’s findings, an OnlyFans spokesperson said the platform prioritises user safety and operates strict onboarding, payment controls and moderation systems. The company also stated it is not connected to or responsible for third-party management agencies and said it complies with relevant UK online safety legislation.

The documentary also includes commentary from MP Tonia Antoniazzi, who called for greater scrutiny of the sector and suggested Parliament should consider formal investigations into how the ecosystem operates, arguing that current regulation has not kept pace with technological change.

OnlyFans: Inside the Machine airs on BBC Three at 9pm and BBC One at 10:55pm, and is available to stream on BBC iPlayer.